The $55 Home Yogurt Maker That Makes Thick, Creamy Greek Yogurt for Pennies per Batch

I love Greek yogurt—but buying it every week adds up fast.

The good stuff is expensive.
The cheap stuff is thin and bland.
And making it on the stovetop always felt like too much work.

So I tried Amazon’s best-selling home yogurt maker, mostly out of curiosity.

A few batches later, I stopped buying store-bought yogurt almost entirely.

Table of Contents

🏆 Quick Verdict (For Yogurt Lovers)

If you eat yogurt regularly, a home yogurt maker pays for itself quickly with better texture, better flavor, and lower cost per batch.

✔ Thick, creamy Greek-style yogurt
✔ Simple set-and-forget process
✔ Control ingredients and sweetness
✔ Costs pennies per serving

👉 Check the current price on Amazon (usually around $45–$60)

The Best-Selling Yogurt Maker on Amazon

Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker

Current Amazon price: ~$45–$60
Best seller status: Top-rated yogurt maker
Capacity: 7 glass jars

This is the one I use:

• Tens of thousands of reviews
• Consistently 4.5⭐+
• Popular with home cooks and meal preppers

It keeps a steady, low fermentation temperature, which is the key to thick, consistent yogurt.

👉 View the Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker on Amazon

Why Homemade Yogurt Is So Much Better

Store-bought yogurt is often:
• Over-sweetened
• Thickened with additives
• More expensive per ounce

Homemade yogurt lets you control:
• Milk quality
• Thickness
• Sweetness
• Probiotic strength

After straining for Greek-style yogurt, the texture rivals premium brands.

What It Costs Per Batch

One batch uses:
• About ½ gallon of milk
• A few tablespoons of starter

That comes out to well under $2 per batch, even using high-quality milk.

Features That Actually Matter

🔹 Simple One-Button Operation
No timers, no apps, no guesswork.

🔹 Glass Jars Included
No plastic taste and easy to store in the fridge.

🔹 Quiet, Overnight Operation
Let it ferment while you sleep.

🔹 Easy Cleanup
Jars go straight into the dishwasher.

Yogurt Maker vs Store-Bought

For consistency and convenience, the machine wins.

Common Questions

Can it make Greek yogurt?
Yes. Strain the finished yogurt with a cheesecloth or strainer.

Is it complicated?
Not at all. Heat milk, cool slightly, add starter, press a button.

Does it save money?
If you eat yogurt weekly, absolutely.

Final Verdict: Worth It?

Without question.

If you want thicker yogurt, fewer additives, and long-term savings, this is one of the best small kitchen investments you can make.

👉 Check the Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker on Amazon

Better yogurt.
Lower cost.
Zero additives.

Affiliate Disclosure:
This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through one, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.